Skip to main content
PolicySpeak
← The ranking

Side by side

Compare organizations

Consultation participation and their own register declarations, side by side. Counts, not judgments — participation is not influence.

Counts here are a floor, never a total: they cover the 583 consultation files tracked so far (42,224 submissions, mostly 2025–26), so an organization's real filing history is larger, not smaller.

II
Insurance Ireland

Industry association · Ireland

4
files engaged
of 583 tracked
6
positions filed
in those 583 files
2.7
declared FTE
self-declared
4
EP accreditations
as declared to the register

Declared costs: €400K+ a year · in the register since 2017

GIA
German Insurance Association (GDV)

Industry association · Germany

35
files engaged
of 583 tracked
44
positions filed
in those 583 files
13.3
declared FTE
self-declared
9
EP accreditations
as declared to the register

Declared costs: €2.8M+ a year · in the register since 2008

Files both filed on (3)

Retail investor protection rules · Framework for Financial Data Access · Review of measures on taking up and pursuit of the insurance and reinsurance business (Solvency II)

Register facts self-declared (snapshot 2 Sept 2026); cost bands are floors. Shared files are shared attention, not evidence of coordination.

What each said, in their own words

Their opening passages on the files they share, verbatim and in filing order. We do not summarize, compare, or characterize positions — read them at source.

Retail investor protection rules

German Insurance Association (GDV) · filed 25 May 2022 · source

We appreciate the opportunity to comment on the call for evidence. While we consider targeted modifications of existing legislation to be appropriate in some points, we are convinced that the current regulation on insurance-based investment products has, for the most part, worked well in practice.

Insurance Ireland · filed 28 Aug 2023 · source

Ireland is a global hub for (re)insurers, captives and insurtechs. Irish insurers service customers across the EU, making Ireland the fourth largest insurance market in the EU and no.1 exporter of life and non-life insurance. Irelands life insurers have an outstanding expertise in providing high-quality services to their customers and allowing them to participate in capital markets.

Framework for Financial Data Access

Insurance Ireland · filed 31 Oct 2023 · source

Insurance Ireland welcomes the FiDA proposal. However, we outline some considerations: Scope.We suggest a phased approach by line of business with pre-defined timelines, starting with motor and home insurance Art.4 requires further clarity especially whether the customer should have the right to access this data themselves, automate such data access with software, or authorize a FISP to access the data on their…

German Insurance Association (GDV) · filed 31 Oct 2023 · source

The German insurance industry generally supports the European considerations to promote a data-driven financial system. With the presented legislative proposal on a framework for access to financial data ("FiDA"), retail and corporate customers are to be given more creative scope in the use of their financial data.

Review of measures on taking up and pursuit of the insurance and reinsurance business (Solvency II)

Insurance Ireland · filed 26 Aug 2020 · source

Insurance Ireland is the representative body of the Irish insurance industry. Ireland is the 5th biggest insurance market in the EU and the 2nd biggest market for reinsurance. Our members serve customers in more than 110 countries including 24 EU Member States. The further integration of the EU single market is the key objective of our vision of an integrated, innovative and sustainable EU single market.

German Insurance Association (GDV) · filed 26 Aug 2020 · source

Summary The German insurance industry supports the modern, risk-based SII regime and believes it works well overall. Its level of security is very high. Particularly in the Covid-19 crisis, SII has proven its worth. Nevertheless, the SII review should be used for some important improvements. Regulations that are overshooting from a risk perspective should be corrected in all three pillars.

Insurance Ireland · filed 11 Jan 2022 · source

Insurance Ireland (II) appreciates the opportunity to provide its feedback on the European Commission’s (EC) proposal to review the Solvency II Directive (hereafter: the Review) and its Communication on its plans to review the Delegated Regulation on Solvency II, (EU) 2015/35.

German Insurance Association (GDV) · filed 12 Jan 2022 · source

The German insurance industry supports the Solvency II review and welcomes many aspects of the European Commission’s proposals. We are convinced that the risk-based Solvency II regulation already ensures a very high level of policyholder protection and contributes significantly to financial stability. Recently, it proved its worth in the challenges of the Covid-19 pandemic.

Insurance Ireland · filed 13 Jan 2022 · source

Insurance Ireland (II) appreciates the opportunity to provide its feedback on the European Commission’s (EC) proposal establishing a framework for the recovery and resolution of (re)insurance undertakings (hereafter: IRRD). II notes that the EC presented IRRD, but did not present a proposal for the harmonisation of Insurance Guarantee Schemes (IGS).

German Insurance Association (GDV) · filed 13 Jan 2022 · source

The German insurance industry supports the objections of strengthening policyholder and consumer protection and financial stability. We also take a positive view of the intended harmonization of resolution tools and the improvement of coordination and cooperation between the competent authorities in the various Member States.

Take this comparison with you

2 organizations on one sheet: every file each filed on, their register declarations, and a working link to each submission. Free: we ask for your name and email, and PolicySpeak may contact you about the product (privacy policy). The per-file record stays downloadable without signing up on each file’s page.