16 submissions from 16 organizations told the European Commission what they think about this file. Here is what each of them said, in their own words.
The Commission lists 42 submissions on this file. Shown here: the 16 from organizations. Not shown, by design: submissions from private individuals, which we never publish, and anything filed since our last weekly refresh.
CommitteeAGRIRapporteurClara Aguilera (S&D)
Published in the Official Journal · 16 Dec 2024
Signed · 27 Nov 2024
Approval of the EP's first reading position by the Council (adoption of the legislative act) · 18 Nov 2024
Discussions within the Council or its preparatory bodies · 26 Jun 2024
Discussions within the Council or its preparatory bodies · 18 Jun 2024
Who showed up
6 submissions from industry — companies and their trade associations — against 8 from civil society: NGOs, consumer organizations, environmental groups and trade unions.
Industry 6Civil society 8Public authorities, academia, other 2
Groupings use the respondent type each organization selected when filing. Counting submissions, not organizations — a body that filed twice is counted twice.
The file, right now
The consultation closed on 1 Jan 2024 — it ran from 24 Oct 2023.
The RMRM encourages the Commission to seize the opportunity of the reform of Regulation (EU) 2016/2031 to make the following amendments: 1. In the context of recitals (43) and (61), it is appropriate to exempt from the obligation to issue plant passports small seed producers (individual producers and micro-enterprises) who work on-farm in the conservation and development of traditional cultivated biodiversity, in…
Filed in French · English published by the European Commission
SEED Luxembourg encourages the Commission to take the opportunity of the reform of Regulation (EU) 2016/2031 to make the following amendments: 1. In the context of recitals (43) and (61), small seed producers (individuals and micro-enterprises) working on-farm for the conservation and development of traditional crop diversity, especially in the area of food crops, who produce small quantities of seeds and plant…
My work of preserving old varieties of vegetables and cereals will be made extremely difficult and almost economically impossible by the new Plant Passport Regulation. Professionally engaged diversity farmers must officially register and comply with a list of obligations if they sell seed and planting material of rare varieties of tomatoes, beans and some other vegetable species or blowers of rare fruit and soot…
Filed in German · English published by the European Commission
Our micro-enterprise (four self-employed entrepreneurs – no employees) is increasing the number of vegetables, flowers and herbs. We sell the seeds via organic retail to final consumers, via web shops and also to gardeners in the region. The preservation of crop diversity is a very important concern for us. More than 150 different plants grow in our 4.000 m² garden each year.
Filed in German · English published by the European Commission
The aim of the gene blade is to list, network and make visible initiatives and organisations on old and rare vegetable varieties in Baden-Württemberg. We welcomed the evaluation of the Plant Health Regulation on plant passport (Article 79). Many of us commented on this in 2021. During the evaluation, a petition was made against the obligation to report to diversity stakeholders.
Filed in German · English published by the European Commission
Ladies and gentlemen, professionally committed diversity producers must officially register and comply with a list of obligations if they sell seeds and plantings of rare varieties of tomatoes, beans and some other vegetable varieties or boysters to hobs to hobby gardeners and if they wish to do so by using a webshop.
Filed in German · English published by the European Commission
I have been running a small fruit farm for 25 years, on which I cultivate a wide variety of historical fruit varieties, including 400 apple varieties, 70 sweet cherry varieties, 160 pear varieties and 40 plum varieties. Many of the varieties are not available in fruit shops or nurseries.
We welcomed the evaluation of the Plant Health Regulation in the field of plant passports (Article 79). Many of us commented on this in 2021. During the evaluation, a petition was launched against the reporting obligation for stakeholders in diversity. More than 10.000 affected people across the EU have signed: https://www.openpetition.eu/.../eine-meldepflicht-fuer....
Filed in Dutch · English published by the European Commission
Good day, the heavy burden of formalities and obligations (notification, traceability, lists, eradication, etc.) unnecessarily complicates the full day-to-day life of micro-enterprises, which make a valuable contribution to maintaining agro-biodiversity. Unnecessary, as the functioning of micro-enterprises entails low risk factors for the spread of diseases and pests.
Filed in German · English published by the European Commission
Plantum, the Dutch association representing companies active in breeding, propagation, cultivation, and marketing of seeds and young plants, welcomes the opportunity to contribute to the public consultation on the targeted amendment of the Plant Health Regulation (EU) 2016/2031. Plantum represents over 300 companies involved in seeds and young plants, boasting an export volume of 4 billion euros in 2022.
I see a great risk that our regional diversity will diminish as a result of further constraints on private owners and conservation organisations. As a conservation organisation, we will be affected by the introduction of a plant passport, as well as other requirements under Article 79 of the Plant Passport, in such a way that we must stop our voluntary work.
Filed in German · English published by the European Commission
The umbrella organisation for crop and livestock diversity brings together 25 organisations in German-speaking countries with the aim of improving the conditions for their on-farm conservation work. Many of us have in 2021 commented the evaluation of the Plant Health Regulation on the subject of plant passports (Article 79).
IRV-CIP Internationaler Rebveredlerverband - Comité international des pépiniéristes viticoles IRV-CIP is an association founded in 1975 that gathers together the national associations of producers of propagating material of vine of: Austria, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Italy, Luxembour, Portugal, Spain, Switzerland.
Asaja Nacional (Agricultural Association of Young Farmers) wishes to draw attention to the following points in the proposal: — Pests provisionally classified as quarantine require clarification on the policy measures. — Regulated non-quarantine plants, amendment of the requirements of the phytosanitary certificate.
Filed in Spanish · English published by the European Commission
Response from the Flower Auctions Association (Vereniging van Bloemenveilingen Nederland, VBN) to the Commissions public consultation on the review proposal for the Plant Health Regulation Aalsmeer, 21 December 2023 VBN represents the interface between the producers of ornamental plants and flowers, and the trade therein. The auctions are cooperatives, owned by the producers.
As Arche Noah, we have been conserving and dynamically managing crop diversity since 1990. Today we have the responsibility to manage one of Europes biggest private collections of cultivated plants, maintaining about 5,500 accessions of mostly crops and crop wild relatives. As our primary aim is to conserve plant genetic resources, plant health is in our utmost interest.
Method. Every quote is verbatim from the organization’s own submission to the European Commission, trimmed to its opening passage and never summarized by a model. Where a submission was filed in another EU language we show the English text the European Commission publishes alongside it, labeled on the quote; the original is one click away at the source. Groupings use the respondent type the organization itself selected when filing. We deliberately do not label anyone “supportive” or “opposed” — you read what they wrote and draw your own conclusion. Organizations only, never individuals. Reused under Commission Decision 2011/833/EU; the European Commission is not liable for this reuse.